Robinson in quit threat over prison plans

Published Tuesday, 15 November 2011
Toggle font size

Justice Minister David Ford says there are no specific plans to change the name and cap badge of the Northern Ireland Prison Service after the First Minister threatened to "resign and force an election" over the issue.

The proposals, which include the removal of the crown from the prison symbol and prison uniforms, form part of fundamental reform outlined by the former Chief Inspector of Prisons, Dame Anne Owers, and her review team.

They were detailed by Mr Ford after the issue was raised by TUV leader Jim Allister in the Assembly on Monday.

Peter Robinson later made it clear that he would take the ultimate step in quitting his job and triggering an election, if the symbolic changes - which have been suggested by the Prison Service - were enforced.

"Not on my watch," the DUP leader told party colleagues.

If we are unable to block it in the Assembly, I will resign my position in order to force an election and allow the electorate to decide the issue.

First Minister Peter Robinson

Speaking to UTV, Mr Robinson added: "This came completely out of the blue - David Ford has never mentioned it to me on any occasion.

"So let's be very clear, he is badly advised if he thinks that this is something that can be done in an operational manner."

Mr Ford, who met with Mr Robinson on Tuesday afternoon, insists that no decisions have been taken.

"As everyone will be aware, we are currently engaged in an extensive programme of reform within the prison system," the justice minister said.

"The issue of symbol is clearly part of the issue of what is under consideration but there are no specific plans or proposals on my desk at present," he told UTV Live.

"Clearly issues of controversy like the symbols would be issues which would have to be discussed by other executive ministers."

Mr Ford described his meeting with Mr Robinson as "sensible and reasoned".

"It was looking at the way forward and I had a similar constructive discussion with Martin McGuinness as well this afternoon," he said.

I cannot give any assurance that the symbols will change or that they will not change.

Justice Minister David Ford

"The challenge for all of us collectively is to work together to deliver the level of prison reform that our community needs," Mr Ford said.

DUP Justice Committee Chairman Paul Givan said he welcomed the clarification "that any change to the Northern Ireland Prison Service symbols or the title used by our prisons would be a matter for the Executive".

"As the largest Party in the Executive, the DUP would veto any attempt to remove Her Majesty from our Prisons' titles," he said.

Earlier Sinn Féin Deputy First Minister Martin McGuinness urged Mr Robinson to "calm down".

He said: "Obviously the whole issue of prison reform is of vital importance.

"That's one of the reasons why Anne Owers and her team were involved in looking at the prison system and are coming forward with very important proposals which will fundamentally change the whole system.

"So let's be sensible about this. Let's be very calm about how we deal with this and I think there should be no knee-jerk reactions."

SDLP member of the Justice committee Colum Eastwood said the First Minister "should focus on the substantive issues".

"Political leaders should not be afforded the luxury at this time of financial turbulence to indulge in controversies surrounding symbolism," he said.

There are big challenges out there and threatening resignations and elections is not what people voted for last May and it is not helpful.

Raymond McCartney, Sinn Féin Assembly Group leader

The chairman of the Prison Officers' Association, Finlay Spratt, has hit out over the proposals and claimed that they would be "a sop to terrorism".

Meanwhile Mr Allister, who tabled a no-confidence motion in the justice minister, described the planned changes as "a calculated insult" to prison officers.

"David Ford's attempt to bring such radical change to the Prison Service without so much as consulting the Assembly shows that he is unfit for office," the North Antrim MLA said.

"If Peter Robinson really is so exercised about Mr Ford's plans, doubtless the DUP will back this (no confidence) proposal," he said.

UUP leader Tom Elliott said he was "outraged" at the proposals and described them as "an insult to the bravery and suffering of the men and women of the Northern Ireland Prison Service".

Responded to Mr Robinson's threat to resign, he added: "The Ulster Unionist Party has long believed that David Ford was little more than a DUP puppet, and the reaction of Mr Robinson to the first decision by Mr Ford that the DUP disagrees with, would tend to confirm those suspicions."

© UTV News
Comments Comments
Joe Soap in Belfast wrote (1,168 days ago):
I had to reread your thread 3 times Tom.Spot on.Is there a law that outlaws my rights?Dont't think so.It is called Democracy Tom.Cromwell is long gone,and well buried.We must move on to a bright brand new day.That rocky road to Dublin is just a spin in the motor,with not a border check in sight.A man who wraps himself in emblems isn't sure of who he truely is.
rod in :) wrote (1,169 days ago):
Avoiding all the important issues as per usual. Sounds like the ole days of shouts from old King Cole himself. Robinson should have gone to the Republic and helped his buddy Martin to secure that illustrious position in the Free State.
John in Belfast wrote (1,169 days ago):
John Hume once said, "You can't eat flags." How right. Reading some of the comments here it is astounding how silly and backward-looking this society is. Any move towards equality in this province is seen by many on the unionist side as a sop to republicans and a betrayal. Churchill seemed to be quite prepared to do a deal with De Valera during WW2 which would have seriously affected NI's status within the UK. Britain doesn't have principles. It merely has interests.
seamas in belfast wrote (1,169 days ago):
Prisoners Officers don’t deserve this. After all sometimes only 4 or five officers on their own without police or army back up had to tackle a dangerous unarmed naked Blanketman. And now this? Disgraceful.
mr craig in england wrote (1,169 days ago):
allen wrote: "Why can't the badge be amended to one similar to that of the PSNI? BTW,the Crown on the badge didn't stop the prison officers being attacked and intimidated by those who profess to be loyal to it." change the badge as with the psni, this is obviously what is going to happen - quite right too!
Email address*:    
House Rules:  
Your Comment:  
[All comments are moderated and will not appear immediately. Your name, location and comment will be displayed on this page if your post passes moderation.]
January snow
Tue 13 January 2015
Ravenhill Road fish spill
Sun 25 January 2015
Wed 07 January 2015