Priest 'won't back down' to Vatican

Published Thursday, 07 February 2013
Toggle font size

A Catholic priest has said he is being threatened with excommunication by the Vatican for not backing down over his liberal views.

Priest 'won't back down' to Vatican
Fr Tony Flannery has been censured by the Catholic Church. (© UTV)

Tony Flannery, 66, is a high-profile and well known priest who has previously spoken out of line with the Church's stance on hot topics such as contraception and homosexuality.

The Galway Redemptorist priest revealed last month that he was ordered to sign a pledge by the church that he supports their teachings.

He can now no longer minister as a priest and is being threatened with excommunication by the Vatican.

"They wanted me to sign and publish a document on these issues stating that I accepted fully the Vatican's position on them which I wouldn't have been able to do without turning my back on things I've been saying for 30 years," he explained.

"It was a very difficult year for me, for most of the year I was forbidden to minister as a priest and then as it went on I was told that I would never again minister as a priest unless I gave them the statement that they were looking for."

"To be told that you can no longer do what you had done all your life and what you had loved doing was very difficult."

He says that he has received a lot of support from his family, colleagues, and parishioners since going public about the rift.

He said: "I have been getting massive support from the Catholic people in Ireland through the last 11 months, all that has been a great help."

I cannot violate my conscience and I have to be able to live with myself for the rest of my life. If you lose your integrity, you lose your sense of respect for yourself.

Father Tony Flannery

Another priest who was censured by the Vatican was Father Brian D'arcy.

The popular Fermanagh preacher was reprimanded for his views on priests being able to marry and his criticism of the child abuse scandals.

"I felt saddened that after 50 years of giving your life to an organisation that some person thought I was untrustworthy," he said at the time.

"It was very hurtful."

Fr D'arcy vowed to continue his work in the media, despite being ordered that he must have all contributions to the media approved by the Vatican, but he was allowed to keep practicing.

Irish Times journalist, Patsy McGarry claims the Vatican has taken a hard line with priests stepping out of line with the church.

"Fr Tony Flannery would be a very popular figure in Ireland, he would be very well known," he told UTV.

"He is one of quite a number of prominent priests who have been silenced by the Church in recent times, all of whom have a number of things in common.

"They tended to be sympathetic to people who are having difficulty with church teachings on issues such as contraception, women in the priesthood, teaching on homosexuality.

"They tended to be more compassionate in their interpretation of church teachings and this is reflected in their writings."

Mr McGarry said that Rome has been tough on bringing these priests in line with the orthodoxy as part of a response to recent crises.

"Rome it seems is blaming a liberal interpretation of church teaching for the abuse that took place in the Irish Catholic Church involving priests going back decades," he claimed.

"The implication being, that people were too liberal in their interpretation, too tolerant in their application of church teaching, if they had been rigorous in terms of church law, in terms of church dogma, this wouldn't have happened.

"It doesn't stand up to scrutiny. It is frankly nonsensical because some of the bishops who oversaw the abuse in for instance, the Dublin archdiocese and in Cloyne archdiocese, would be among the most orthodox men, conservative Irish catholic leaders we have had in the 21st century."

Fr Flannery is intent on standing by his words, but he admitted the decision has been very "lonely and personal".

He said the ban from active priesthood has been the worst consequence for him and that if the ban is not lifted, he will need to "move on".

The priest said his faith remains unfaltering, and that he sees a distinction between God and the church.

"No matter what the church does to me, nothing can become between me and my faith in God."

© UTV News
Comments Comments
lucylou in belfast wrote (696 days ago):
BORU IN IRELAND===Don't know what a gormy meal is but an AGAPE meal is [a simple meal of brotherly love celebrated in apostolic times in connection with the Lord's supper;it was a simple feast of unity;]
lucylou in belfast wrote (701 days ago):
JIM AND VEE IN BELFAST===Do you believe no r catholic uses birth control ie the pill,condoms etc etc OR that there are no practising homosexuals attending mass and taking communion OR that no r catholics 'live in sin' and have children outside of marriage? Jesus met and ministered to people where THEY were,served by EXAMPLE did not condemn.MAYBE ,JUST MAYBE if we all followed his example and tried a little harder to follow his commands of loving GOD with all heart soul and mind and our neighbours as ourselves we could leave people to their own conscience in these matters after hearing ALL opinions.
Colin in South Down wrote (720 days ago):
Kelly: This has nothing to do with the terrible abuse children suffered. That is a smoke screen. Note, Fr. Flannery is excommunicating himself, the Vatican's role in this would just be to formalise his decision.
Jim in Belfast wrote (721 days ago):
Pat in Comber.... The Catholic church is not going to simply "tell you what you want to hear" just to put bums in seats. You say no wonder we are laughed at for out views?? The Catholic church is the biggest religion in the world all with people sharing these "views". If you dont like it then dont follow it. There are plenty of churches out there that have "moved with the times" that yourself and this priest can follow, dont expect a church to rose tint its beliefs to keep you as a member. The vatican are still paying his wages and putting a roof over his head, if he was that annoyed by it all he would/should leave. And Kelly seeing you have turned this into an "abuse related" debate ill remind you that ANY honest and good priest actively condems any abuse NOT just this priest. The article is in realtion to priests marrying and contraception, nothing about abuse, seems to me your one of these people who like to jump on the abuse bandwagon anytime you hear the word "priest" mentioned.
John in Newtownabbey wrote (721 days ago):
Well said Kelly in Dungannon. How dare the Church forget it has a woeful track record and should hang its head in shame. To make such threats against a sincere cleric is totally absurd - just as absurd as Sean Brady's excuses and denials of responsibility in the cover up. Just following orders or procedures was the excuse trotted out by the Nazis who murdered millions. I vote with my feet and my pocket and have put my faith into perspective due to situations just like Frs Flannery and D'arcy find themselves in.
Email address*:    
House Rules:  
Your Comment:  
[All comments are moderated and will not appear immediately. Your name, location and comment will be displayed on this page if your post passes moderation.]
January snow
Tue 13 January 2015
Wintry weather
Wed 28 January 2015
Ravenhill Road fish spill
Sun 25 January 2015