Price tag for policing parades revealed

Published Friday, 14 October 2011
Comments
Toggle font size
Print

Nearly £6m has been spent on policing parades in Northern Ireland in just five months.

Figures from the PSNI show that £5.7m was poured into dealing with parades and resulting public disorder between April and August 2011.

Assistant Chief Constable Alistair Finlay said that the policing operations "facilitated human rights and protected communities".

He added: "The vast majority of parades passed off peacefully - however, unfortunately, violence broke out in a few small areas during the summer.

"This was not representative of the vast majority of communities across Northern Ireland who are working side by side for a better future."

The statistics, which were compiled at the request of the Policing Board, revealed that £2.2m was needed to police the Twelfth of July period alone.

Trouble specifically in Ardoyne on 12 and 13 July cost the taxpayer nearly £800,000.

The cost incurred as a result of disorder in east Belfast and Ballyclare was not included, as it was not directly linked to any parades.

Given current pressures on the policing budget and the public purse, I have no doubt the wider community will share the concerns of Policing Board members on this issue.

Conall McDevitt, SDLP

"Whilst policing costs are broadly similar to those of previous years, these figures are still shocking," the SDLP's Conall McDevitt said.

Speaking as chairman of the Policing Board's Human Rights and Professional Standards Committee, he added that existing pressures on budgets and resources would make such costs a real public concern.

"For communities that have been affected by serious public disorder, there is a much wider cost that is not measurable in monetary terms but has a very serious community impact".

DUP Policing Board member Robin Newton said the figures were in effect "the cost of cultural intolerance" and called for more respect for differences between communities.

"Parades not only enrich the cultural diversity of Northern Ireland, but they can actually act as an economic driver through increasing our tourism," he said.

"However, opposition to parades driven largely on intolerance and bigotry not only costs our society in terms of the tensions created, but places a real financial cost onto the police which could be better spent tackling crime."

Sinn Féin Policing Board member Gerry Kelly claimed dialogue was the "simple solution" to the problem of policing parades and added that the onus was on the Orange Order.

"The agreement over the future of parading reached last year at the Executive produced a legislative way forward, however yet again the Orange Order blocked its acceptance," he said.

"There is a huge number of parades that take place each year and they cause no offence and very little cost. If everyone sits down round the table on an equal basis, then these few contentious parades can be resolved if there is a will there to do it."

Parades Commission Chairman Peter Osborne says the figures are "a sobering reminder of the cost of contention around disputed parades".

"We believe there is an onus on elected politicians, parade organisers, community and civic leaders and others to engage in dialogue and to work towards agreement in those few remaining areas where contention remains," he said.

© UTV News
Comments Comments
38 Comments
seamas in belfast wrote (218 days ago):
Mark O. As you can see I like to get the last word. I welcome your suggestion that lodges should contribute to policing costs. That would bring the OO into line with other groups, Football Clubs etc who have to pay for their policing. I also accept that there are moderating voices within the Order particular those with a genuine religious faith. What we need the OO and the wider protestant community to accept is that our objection to parades past our homes is genuine. It’s too easy for unionists to dismiss nationalist objections or complaints as malicious. I’ve listened to unionist spokespersons down through the years, both politicians and lay people and there is a common thread that runs through all of them. That is that they constantly seek to reinterpret what nationalists say. If we complain about the police it’s because we’re republicans or we’re trouble makers. If we complain about parades it’s because the Shinners have bullied us into it. They will consider any explanation for our objection except the real one. Unionists never believe that nationalists are genuine. That in turn is fed by a low level bigotry which casts Catholics as mischievous and untrustworthy. The one way to prove that Catholics are accepted at face value is to listen and take heed of our objections to parades past our homes. Make no mistake about it no nationalist wants to stop Orange parades happening. We just would like the OO to take another road if we feel the parade is offensive or inconvenient. Another road which is also the Queen’s highway.
Mark O in Londonderry wrote (219 days ago):
Seamas I agree, it's good to talk. On topic of OO I personally think it's a disgrace that members cannot attend Catholic Worship. It's an old outdated rule that has to be addressed and changed. I also think each Lodge or Band should pay say a Standard £1000 towards Policing costs each and every time they apply to march. Same for ABOD, AOH, SF etc. Also if a Protest is organised then whoever organises it must also pay towards Policing. Anyone convicted of rioting should be fined £10000, which of course would go into the Policing Budget, or face a mimimum 2 years in Prison That would be a good way to cut the number of Parades and amount of Rioting. Seamas you have your opinions on the OO and that's fair enough. However not all Orangemen are Intolerant Bigots who hate Catholics. There are many many moderate Unionists within the OO who are working away in the background to bring about changes. I expect the rule on attendind Catholic worship to be changed soon or there will be a few people leaving the Order! Have a good day Seamas...
seamas in belfast wrote (219 days ago):
Mark O. Congratulations on your mathematical prowess. Whatever way you cut it however the majority of policing costs arise from the parades themselves and not from public disturbances. Yet proponents of parading consistently come on to sites like this and tell us that it’s the protests that cost all the money. It’s good that we’re discussing parading costs. That’s a step in the right direction. Now here’s the thing. The OO is a grossly sectarian anti catholic organisation. That much is self evident from its stance on attendance at the funerals of murdered catholic security force members. It is also an entirely private organisation. It has no official status; it is not a state body. Why should we continue to pay vast sums of money to an organisation that openly and with such relish denigrates half the population? Why should we continue to fund a group which won’t cooperate with our parades commission and won’t meet our elected representatives? An organisation that has attacked our police force and courts extreme elements within loyalism? This is the UK. No other group in the UK would be allowed to behave like that.
Ulysses32 in Belfast wrote (220 days ago):
Mark O, if you are going to make assumptions and you try to present them as fact, I'll call you a numpty as well. Can you provide a link to the clear and documented breakdown of your spurious assumptions. Other than the information presented by the PSNI can you substantiate anything you have presented. Thought not, the title of numpty is quite fitting, then.
english mr craig in england wrote (221 days ago):
the british think you irish are nuts for forking out six million quid on yearly parades that apparently show some lunatic loyalty to us. it's ridiculous! spend £6m on the ulster economy and perhaps this may help reduce the dreadful rate of suicides that blights your land... jesus wept, i mean really!
POST A COMMENT:
Name:  
Email address*:    
Location:  
Validation:
House Rules:  
Your Comment:  
[All comments are moderated and will not appear immediately. Your name, location and comment will be displayed on this page if your post passes moderation.]
MOST POPULAR GALLERIES