Press regulation a 'toothless tiger'

Published Monday, 18 March 2013
Comments
Toggle font size
Print

A newspaper editor in Northern Ireland fears new changes in the law, aimed at regulating the press, will be ineffective and restrictive.

Video available to UK viewers only.
We’re sorry. This video is unavailable from your location.
  • This video has been Geoblocked to UK viewers ONLY!
    Press report
  • This video has been Geoblocked to UK viewers ONLY!
    Interview: Mark Durkan

To find out if this video is available to you, we need to know what region you live in. Please enter your postcode below (including space).

Frequently Asked Questions

Thank you for confirming your region.

Frequently Asked Questions

We are sorry but this video is not available on u.tv in your region. Your region is listed below.

Frequently Asked Questions

Are you in Northern Ireland?

1. Why is my postcode required?

We are asking you to insert your postcode before watching some videos to confirm you can access the video content via u.tv.

This is because some videos on u.tv are only available in Northern Ireland.

Don't worry, we won't store or use this information for any other purpose.

If you are not in Northern Ireland, the content may be available to watch at itv.com or stv.tv.

2. Why am I directed to itv.com or stv.tv when I try to view certain clips?

The videos, which are not available on u.tv to users outside Northern Ireland, will be available to those users on itv.com (for users in England and Wales) or stv.tv (for most users in Scotland).

We need to know where you are in order to make sure you are getting the right content.

If you think we've got your location wrong, then please click here.

Need more help? Contact us

Prime Minister David Cameron said the reforms, set up in the wake of the Leveson inquiry, will defend the principles of the free press.

The new body will be created by Royal Charter, but the emergency debate surrounding the new system has revealed confusion over whether or not the press will be legally obliged to sign up.

Lord Justice Leveson had recommend that a new regulation body should be underpinned by legislation, but Mr Cameron previously warned that could risk "crossing the Rubicon" towards a press law.

On Monday, he said the Royal Charter was a way of establishing the recognition body "without the need to write down in legislation the title, the definition, the functions, the power, the rules or the composition of a new system of regulation".

But Mr Cameron acknowledged that legislation was necessary to establish a system of exemplary damages for newspapers which did not sign up to the regulator.

Jim McDowell, Northern Editor of the Sunday World, said there is no need for the new body, and described it as a "toothless tiger".

"It's like being in jail. We've the most restrictive press in any democracy on the western world or anywhere else," he commented.

"I agree there was a huge problem in phone hacking but that's criminal activity, let the police deal with that."

However media lawyer Paul Tweed said it appears the optional system will not act as a strong enough deterrent to prevent press from crossing lines it has already breached.

"I, as a practicing media lawyer, need to have a situation where a client comes into me and tells me: 'I have been given four hours notice that a newspaper is going to publish serious allegations about me, they are not true how can I stop them?'

"We contact the press - as happened in the case of Louis Walsh for instance - and we are invariably faced with a situation of publish and be damned.

"I cannot see anything that I have heard in the past 24 hours that is going to act as deterrent," he added.

The move has been backed by all three major parties, and Labour leader Ed Miliband said the Commons was "doing the right thing".

"I want to pay tribute to the victims who have had the courage to stand up and make their voices heard - the McCanns, the Dowlers, the Watsons and, yes, their representatives," he stated.

"Today is the day we stand up for them. Today is above all their day."

© UTV News
Comments Comments
0 Comments
No comments. Be the first to comment.
POST A COMMENT:
Name:  
Email address*:    
Location:  
Validation:
House Rules:  
Your Comment:  
[All comments are moderated and will not appear immediately. Your name, location and comment will be displayed on this page if your post passes moderation.]
MOST POPULAR GALLERIES
UVF centenary parade
Sat 20 April 2013
BGT auditions - Week 2
Sat 20 April 2013