Poots halts all care home closures

Published Friday, 03 May 2013
Toggle font size

Health Minister Edwin Poots has called a halt to the planned closure of residential care homes in Northern Ireland.

Poots halts all care home closures
Edwin Poots visits Westland care home. (© Pacemaker)

It follows an emergency meeting with the five Health Trust bosses on Friday afternoon.

Mr Poots has ordered the trusts to drop their current proposals and begin a new process which places "the principle of sensitivity to the needs and wishes of older people" at its core.

Speaking after the meeting, the DUP minister said: "It is unacceptable that any older person feels distressed because of proposals for change.

"Older people and their families have been left upset and alarmed. That should never be the by-product of a process which is all about improving the lives of older people and giving them more control. This is why we will have a fresh start.

This is about listening to our older people and their families and our own staff.

Edwin Poots

"I expect a process which not only identifies the needs of each individual affected by proposed changes, but also understands the wishes of every single individual and their families. I expect these wishes to be respected, and this extends to all staff."

Sue Ramsey, who chairs the Health Committee at Stormont, said "common sense" prevailed.

The Sinn Féin MLA continued: "Common sense has prevailed and clearly the situation has been handled wrongly. The minister has shown that he is in charge, something he should have done from the beginning of this fiasco.

"The policy of Transforming Your Care is about making our health system better and bringing that care into the community, not spreading fear and uncertainty about the future."

Mr Poots summoned the trust chiefs after it emerged that the Western Trust had earmarked all of its homes for closure, with similar proposals in place in the northern and southern areas.

He defended the Transforming Your Care scheme - which was to close around half of homes - but said he won't stand by the closure of all homes in the next five months.

Local politicians and unions have called for the minister to resign.

UUP leader Mike Nesbitt said: "The issue is simple. Either the minister did not realise this was a sensitive issue, in which case he is not fit for office.

"Or, if he was aware of the sensitivities, he failed to prevent deep and unnecessary hurt, trauma and distress to many elderly people and their families. Either way, surely it is a resignation matter for a man of principle."

Kevin McCabe of NIPSA said: "The dogmatic mantra of private sector good, public sector bad must end or it will have serious ramifications for the present and future health of NI people.

It is clear to NIPSA the Health Service in Northern Ireland is in crisis.


"NIPSA therefore calls for a halt to the implementation of Transforming Your Care and furthermore for the resignation of the Health Minister."

UNISON has also described Mr Poots' position as untenable.

Questions had been asked about why the Trusts were going above and beyond the 50% closure plans of the TYC reforms, which were focused on helping elderly people live at home.

Claire Keatinge, the Commissioner for Older People, said: "I think the question is simple.

"Transforming Your Care proposed a reduction in the number of places in statutory and other residential care, there is a reduce in demand for residential care as more people are cared for in the community and that is proper and that is right.

"There is currently an abject failure of leadership across the Health and Social Care Trusts, across the social care board and from the Minister to join up how he is going to consult on the process by which consideration is given to which if any care homes should close."

Serious concerns were raised by the Patient and Client Council. It said: "Decisions must be taken with residents and their families - not for them."

Professor Michael O'Flaherty from the NI Human Rights Commission also voiced "deep" concerns over "potentially inhuman and degrading treatment" of those living in homes.

Meanwhile residents at several of the affected homes vowed to fight to keep them open.

Roy Beggs of the UUP said: "What must happen now is for the Minister and his senior officials from the Health and Social care Board to be upfront and tell us what TYC will really mean in practice. The bottom line is the Minister has failed, confidence is shattered, and we are all in a much worse place than we were before the DUP took over the Department of Health."

Conall McDevitt of the SDLP said: "The minister needs to start asking fundamental questions about how the trusts were able to take steps in implementing proposals, which were in direct conflict with the departmental policy contained in the Transforming Your Care document."

© UTV News
Comments Comments
disaffected citizen in Belfast wrote (633 days ago):
Poots along with Sammy Wilson and Peter Robinson, the handling of the flags issue, the waste of £10,000 by Sammy Wilson over more flags, the what can only be described as farcical regarding care home closures, the DUP seem to be stumbling from one fiasco to another. Time to go guys, time for fresh thinking and someone to move this country forward.
Robert in Belfast wrote (635 days ago):
U turn to save his position. When the outcry has faded he will bring in the closures through the back door. This is all about stripping the public services and privatising them for profit.
p fla in glengormley wrote (635 days ago):
Well done Mr.Poots. How could the press media and photographers etc just happen to be in position for your cup of tea. A residential setting looks perfect. Cutting services is not what the minister ordered. Its time that Stormont residents were held to account.
Mairead in Belfast wrote (636 days ago):
Get poots out! He has messed up continually during his time as a minister and blamed everyone else! Has a draconion single minded selfish approach to everything and only changes his mind when forced to! Get him out!
James in Ballymena wrote (636 days ago):
Hubris, hubris and yet more hubris is what happened here. Senior Trust managers, emboldened by their actions in trampling over their staff in recent years, thought that they could do the same to the public. They sought to get shot of the residential home problem all in one go to save money and further consultations but they miscalculated badly and it has backfired. If any of their staff had made such appalling errors of professional judgement and caused such distress, they would not have hesitated to have disciplined them. They should be disciplined themselves or even demoted without delay.
Email address*:    
House Rules:  
Your Comment:  
[All comments are moderated and will not appear immediately. Your name, location and comment will be displayed on this page if your post passes moderation.]
January snow
Tue 13 January 2015
Wintry weather
Wed 28 January 2015
Ravenhill Road fish spill
Sun 25 January 2015