PSNI flag protest appeal fast-tracked

Published Friday, 16 May 2014
Toggle font size

PSNI Chief Constable Matt Baggott's appeal against a ruling that police wrongly facilitated illegal loyalist flag protest marches is to be fast-tracked.

PSNI flag protest appeal fast-tracked
PSNI want the hearing fast-tracked due to its impact on managing protests. (© Presseye)

Senior judges agreed to list the challenge for hearing next month after being told it involves issues of operational importance for how the PSNI deals with parades.

In April the High Court held that a police commander misdirected himself in believing he was hampered by law from stopping the parades and arresting participants.

The PSNI's handling of the demonstrations was also found to have breached the human rights of a nationalist resident exposed to accompanying disorder.

The verdict was delivered in a case over weekly processions from east Belfast into the city centre during December 2012 and January 2013.

Demonstrations were staged in response to the decision to restrict the flying of the Union flag at City Hall.

A man who lives in the nationalist Short Strand district went to court in a bid to quash the PSNI's failure to provide assurances that it would prevent any future parade past his home.

He claimed this breached his privacy and family life entitlements under Article 8 of the European Convention on Human Rights.

It was also contended that police failure to prevent the parades contravened both the Public Processions (NI) Act 1998 and the Police (NI) Act 2000.

Lawyers for the resident, identified only as DB, argued that no notification was given for any of the parades in December or January.

Police instead allowed un-notified processions to take place and failed to arrest those involved in organising and taking part, they claimed.

DB's legal team contended that he had been left "besieged" by the serious disorder, violence and attacks on his home.

Mr Justice Treacy held that Assistant Chief Constable Will Kerr, the commander in charge of the PSNI operation around the protests, was "labouring under a material misapprehension" in believing police were hampered from stopping the parades by either the 1998 Act or human rights legislation.

During the period in question police did not behave proactively in relation to prosecuting those organising and participating in the parades, the judge found.

In his assessment ACC Kerr did not appear to have fully appreciated that an un-notified parade has the same status as one which takes place in defiance of a Parades Commission determination.

He also described the policing operation at that time as being characterised by "unjustified enforcement inertia".

Immediately after his verdict was delivered the Chief Constable confirmed it would be challenged.

Counsel representing the PSNI went into the Court of Appeal on Friday to request an early hearing.

Tony McGleenan QC told judges: "The issue in this case is one of some operational importance to police in terms of managing processions.

"I have been asked to seek an expedited hearing of the appeal."

But according to DB's barrister the court may first have to decide whether the issue is now academic.

Lord Chief Justice Sir Declan Morgan then agreed to have the case put into the list for June.

© UTV News
Comments Comments
rammit in belfast wrote (215 days ago):
so its ok to swamp loyalist protests but republicans can have protests with one police vehicle watching how about investigating religious discrimination and inequallity of loyalists by psni surely that would make more sense ?
Jim in Belfast wrote (215 days ago):
The wheels of justice move fast when it suits the PSNI. Meanwhile victims of state killings are waiting in some cases over 40 years for inquests due to procrastination and legal roadblocks put up by the PSNI. Many relatives of victims have been forced all the way to the European Courts. How can any society have faith or confidence in policing like this?
Jos in Belfast wrote (216 days ago):
This is a simple case of the police letting the orange marchers do whatever they like same way as the RUC did in the past.
Ballysillan in Ballysillan wrote (216 days ago):
This should be a fun marching seson. God only knows with all the protesters getting jailed and all the ira bombers getting bailed the goverment must think the whole country is daft. Time to look for new footings this wee place we called home has be sold out.
John in Newtownabbey wrote (216 days ago):
Get a grip Matt. You failed dismally. You're Doubtless worried about leaving the job under a cloud and being unemployable in some highly paid quango that you want to join.
Email address*:    
House Rules:  
Your Comment:  
[All comments are moderated and will not appear immediately. Your name, location and comment will be displayed on this page if your post passes moderation.]
Mon 08 December 2014
One Direction fever
Fri 05 December 2014
U2 music video filmed in Belfast
Wed 17 December 2014