Health committee's Cuba trip criticised

Published Thursday, 20 September 2012
Comments
Toggle font size
Print

The decision to send the chair and vice-chair of the Stormont Health committee on a fact-finding mission to Cuba has been criticised.

Health committee's Cuba trip criticised
An ambulance on the streets of Havana, Cuba. (© Getty)

Sinn Féin's Sue Ramsey and the DUP's Jim Wells will make the trip to attend a conference featuring experts from around the world and to see health projects in the country first-hand.

Alliance MLA Kieran McCarthy has said the trip is "not justified" and that the same knowledge could have been gathered by the use of video-conferencing.

"I am, however, glad that the original idea of sending the whole committee to Cuba was withdrawn after I raised objections," he said.

"There was even a suggestion of sending a committee member from each of the five parties which was also withdrawn."

He added: "After Basil McCrea's aborted attempt to take the whole Employment and Learning committee to San Diego was heavily criticised, I am surprised that this proposal was put forward."

Communist Cuba is known for its strong public healthcare system, although it has been criticised for the low pay of its doctors and the poor state of some facilities.

Cuba is known for being able to deliver excellent health outcomes, despite spending considerably less than most European countries - including Northern Ireland.

Jim Wells

"The Cuba model may not be transferable to Northern Ireland considering that they are a communist country and, being in the Caribbean, they obviously have a different climate," Mr McCarthy said.

"I understand that their salaries are different to ours and pay is obviously a big part of our Health budget, so I do not know how much we can copy them."

The average life expectancy in Cuba is 77.7. While the average for Northern Ireland is 77, that figure falls to around 71 in parts of Belfast.

Committee chair Sue Ramsey said: "Tackling health inequalities is a key priority for the Committee.

"Cuba is well known across the world for its success in terms of improving public health, particularly through an emphasis on primary care and close working between health professionals and their patients, so that early signs of ill-health are quickly identified and treated.

"Lessons can be learned from Cuba which can be applied to how we take forward our new Public Health Strategy."

Deputy chair Jim Wells added: "We are facing wide-ranging changes to our health system following the review of healthcare and the publication of Transforming Your Care.

One of the key recommendations coming out of that report is a shift towards more services being provided through primary care settings.

"Cuba's health system is very much focused on community-based clinics staffed by multi-disciplinary teams - we will able to see first-hand how this works and if it could be applied in Northern Ireland."

© UTV News
Comments Comments
5 Comments
clinton ewing in larne wrote (245 days ago):
what a joke!! I pay my taxes, can I go as well to see we can develop our health service ! the answer is so easy more doctors and nurses please and don't close hospitals. we are in a mess due to recent decisions, but is anyone going to listen "no" the trip will not make any different to me or any other tax payer as its not going to reduce what we pay in taxes but what a waste nevertheless ... would this trip not be best suited for doctors from A&E who are on the front line dealing with everyday problems.
Tomc in Belfast wrote (246 days ago):
So in order to understand a healthcare system, we send unqualified MLAs??? Hows about you send medically qualified persons and then....shock horror...listen to what they have to say for a change! The stupid decisions made up at Billy Smart's Circus aka Stormont just keep getting worse!
Tommy in Limavady wrote (246 days ago):
Fair play to them, MLA's have been claiming expenses, taking wee trips and basically taking the hand for years so they might aswell take a wee jolly to the sun. Apparently ole Jim lost the draw and had to go with wee Sue, never mind!!
Ryan in Belfast wrote (246 days ago):
Cuba has one of the best health care systems in the world. I think it would be worth taxpayers money to send MLA's out there in person to find out the facts and to gain a great insight into Cubas healthcare. Healthcare in NI is far too high and could be of a better standard.
Martin in Belfast wrote (246 days ago):
Surely there should be some sort of oversight or appropriations committee to sign off on these trips so that MLAs arent globetrotting at the taxpayers expense and are justifying the cost and benefits it will have
POST A COMMENT:
Name:  
Email address*:    
Location:  
Validation:
House Rules:  
Your Comment:  
[All comments are moderated and will not appear immediately. Your name, location and comment will be displayed on this page if your post passes moderation.]
MOST POPULAR GALLERIES
On the rocks
Wed 01 May 2013
4x4 in Ballycastle harbour
Thu 02 May 2013