UTV News - Death driver gets suspended sentence

Subscribe to the News Feed Newsback to News

Death driver gets suspended sentence

Text Size:  A  A |  POST A COMMENT |  PRINT |  SHARE 
Adele Whiteside
There was uproar in a Belfast court on Monday as a self-confessed killer driver walked free with an 18-month suspended jail term.

Family and friends of Adele Whiteside, 14, killed as she crossed the road on the way home from a friend's wedding in September two years ago, reacted with fury as Crown Court Judge Geoffrey Miller QC handed the term to Martin Thomas McDonnell.

There were calls of "disgrace, absolute disgrace" launched from the packed public gallery as McDonnell was led away from the dock.

On the morning his trial was due to begin in October McDonnell, 20, from Garnock in Belfast, pleaded guilty to causing her death by dangerous driving.

There were, the court heard, no aggravating factors.

Knocked down as she crossed Finaghy Road South, the teenager was flung into the air, landed over 50 metres way and tragically was pronounced dead at the scene.

In handing down the term, suspended for three years, Judge Miller said victim impact reports "reflect the searing pain and sense of loss" felt by Adele's family, her "young and vibrant life cut short" because McDonnell was driving too fast and not keeping a proper look-out on the road ahead.

"Nothing that this court can do can turn back the clock and restore a young life cut so tragically short to those to whom she meant most," said the judge, "but it is important that in approaching the task of sentencing, the court is aware and mindful of the hurt that has been caused and the wounds that will never heal."

Speaking outside the court Adele's father Alan, mother Shirley and sister Alana, lambasted the sentence as a "disgrace".

Shaking with emotion and anger, Mrs Whiteside said the entire family are still "absolutely heartbroken" over the death of "the greatest person you ever seen in your life".

"We are not the only family going through it all," said the extremely tearful mother, "something has to change in the justice system where they're [killer drivers] put away - I would've put him away and threw away the key...there's nobody getting justice anywhere."

At the time of the accident McDonnell had a clear criminal record.

In May last year, he was involved in a police chase after officers stopped him from taking his life from a motorway bridge.

Judge Miller said his failed suicide bid came as a direct result of the guilt he felt.

The judge revealed that from psychiatric reports, McDonnell tried suicide again at this time last year but that since then, "the risk of his attempting to repeat this in the future has diminished".

© UTV News

Send to a friend

Email To
Your Name
Comment
Close
At 22:26 on 18 February 2010, aaron wrote:
do u think the driver is made of stone? for christ sake people the fella is sorry 4 what he did!! where was Adele's adult supervision at this point?
At 17:30 on 04 December 2009, josie wrote:
By no means is the young driver a killer, as a long friend of his I can say he has never felt so much guilt of an ACCIDENT!!! He without sin cast the first stone. I doubt many people have always stuck to the speed limit..
At 03:02 on 04 December 2009, John wrote:
Believe or like it or not Heather, law is a little more complicated than just those "FACTS" Anyone not familiar (more than just those two FACTS) with that tragic case should hold their naive misinformed judgments about sentencing to themselves.
At 19:11 on 02 December 2009, Heather wrote:
Ref John circumstances !!! the FACTS speak for themselves this man was speeding !!!! and this young girl is dead !!!! FACT!!!!!!!!
At 16:00 on 01 December 2009, allan wrote:
Adele was my daughter and is missed so much. Where was justice yesterday, the police done their job but still a killer walked free. Shame on judge Millar
At 00:16 on 01 December 2009, Margaret wrote:
It's about time all the adverts were taken off TV then, (up to 10 years in jail???) they are obviously as bit a pile of S*** As the justice system. I weekly read the papers and the more sever the crime the more leniant the punishment. Sure lock up all the good people and let the rest ruin northern ireland. Lets send out a warning to everyone, kill someone and you'll get off with it. Thats our law????? What a complete pile of crap!!! Does any judge know the meaning of the word justice??? I wonder of it had been his daughter would he have passed the same sentence??? Answer - absolutely not!! Total and utter disgrace!!!!
At 22:31 on 30 November 2009, Clare wrote:
This whole situation makes me feel ill! how can the the government cry about speeding and danger on the roads, when there is barely a sentence in place for driving along and killing an innocent pedestrian?! not only is the sentence heartbreaking for a suffering family, it also almost accepts speeding! they have laid the groundwork for people to get away with speeding and killing people, so long as they were sober?! is this ok now? there is a lot to be said here for the "justice" system!
Post a comment
Name:
Email Address:
Location:
Your Comment:
Verification Code: Captcha Code  Get New Code
POST COMMENT
[Before posting, please take a moment to familiarise yourself with our house rules. All comments are moderated and will not appear immediately. Any information you enter, including email and web addresses, will be displayed on our site if passed by our moderators.]