City A&E closure 'a disgrace'

Published Wednesday, 07 September 2011
Comments
Toggle font size
Print

The decision to approve temporary closure of Belfast City Hospital's Accident and Emergency unit in November has been greeted by shouts branding it "a disgrace".

Video available to UK viewers only.
We’re sorry. This video is unavailable from your location.

About 100 members of unions Unison and NIPSA protested outside the hospital, as the board of Belfast's Health Trust met on Wednesday morning.

Demonstrators held up banners saying "A&E saves lives", while chanting: "Save our A&E."

The casualty department was due to close temporarily at the end of September due to a shortage of senior doctors - but it emerged the move has been postponed until November.

Belfast Trust Chief Executive Colm Donaghy insisted the first priority was to provide a safe service to patients.

"We will now put in place alternative arrangements and communicate these widely with the public so that anyone who has a health emergency will clearly know where to go to receive treatment," he said.

Board of Belfast Trust approves 'temporary' closure of A&E at City Hospital by 1st Nov. Shouts of 'it's a disgrace'.

UTV’s Sarah Clarke on Twitter (@sarahclarke_utv)

Tommy Brownlee from NIPSA told UTV the union was told the issue was staffing - not finances or politics.

"Apparently middle grade doctors can't be recruited," he said.

"The executive board was asked why it did not occur to anyone that doctors would be needed to staff an Accident and Emergency department."

SDLP South Belfast MP Dr Alasdair McDonnell condemned the Trust's closure decision.

"This decision displays a disingenuous effort on the part of the Trust. I believe that the Trust has not given a genuine effort to secure the senior staffing required," he said.

"In circumstances where the Royal's casualty is already working to capacity in a temporary building, there will be nowhere for the current A & E clientele of the City Hospital to move to - I appeal to the Trust to start putting patients first and reverse this decision."

South Belfast UUP MLA and former Health Minister Michael McGimpsey welcomed the decision to keep the A&E unit open until the start of November, but urged the Department to reverse their plans to ultimately close the unit in coming months.

"As I have repeatedly stated, Accident and Emergency services across the greater Belfast area are already struggling to cope with demand," he said.

"The Royal Hospital is housed in a temporary building and the Ulster is already coping with more than double the number of visits it was built to accommodate.

"I do not believe there is the capacity in the remaining units to cope with up to 50,000 additional visits per year as a result of the City Hospital A & E closure."

DUP Health Spokesman Jim Wells said: "It is important however that both the Royal Victoria Hospital and the Ulster Hospital in particular are able to deal with the increase in patient numbers arising from this closure. Whilst there is a range of work ongoing to ensure this, I and the Heath Committee as a whole will want to receive continued assurances on this. "

Belfast City Hospital's A &E department will close temporarily from 1 November.

© UTV News
Comments Comments
13 Comments
Andrew in Belfast wrote (258 days ago):
@ JACKIE , Its normally the quiet ones in A&E that are in the worst/severe pain, I sat quietly in City Hospital A&E with a broken leg in 2 places from a car accident for just over 2 hours , then told to "just nip down to the Royal" , as the Royal waiting time was less than an hour, because I could of been waiting in the City for another 2 hours due to only ONE doctor being on duty . I obviously was'nt told this when I first went in . I'm all for closing City A&E ..... if it will streamline Mater & Royal A&E departments .
WIGGLE in BELFAST wrote (258 days ago):
Its ok saying that 3 is too many but if you live here you would not think that people come from far and wide to this hospital. About half an hour after the meeting and the cameras left a man suffered a cardiac arrest at the front of the tower block and if it wasn't for the A&E dept and the professionallism of the staff this man would not have survived. How would you like it if that was one of your relatives and there was no A&E dept to treat him.
Jackie in Belfast wrote (258 days ago):
@Jamesbelfast - I totally agree, on the few occasions I have been unfortunate enough to visit an A&E I noticed a lot of people who appeared absolutely fine to me. Some were enjoying a picnic and were quite annoyed when they were disturbed to go and see the nurse/Dr. Another guy was too busy on his mobile phone to hear his name being called.
Jamesbelfast in Belfast wrote (258 days ago):
I agree totally with David Heatley. Reducing the number of A&E's in the Belfast area but making them more efficient makes much more sense. What I would really like to see are figures published either by the Health Minister or Unions (as long as they are accurate) of the number of people who turn up at actually need emergency or urgent treatment. Until this apsect is effectively managed we have no hope of improvement.
Steven in Dunmurry wrote (259 days ago):
The previous posters are missing the point; the protests are not about the reduction in the number of A&E units in Belfast but are about the capacity available at the remaining units and the reasons why the BCH closure has been made. The Belfast Trust has announced that they cannot get enough medics to staff the A&E units and this is some ways correct; but the the senior medics have manipulated this staffing crisis for their own selfish reasons. It is widely rumoured that the same medics have invested in the new private clinic on the Lisburn Road that provides a walk-in casualty treatment service for a fee. Shame on these medics if this is true.
POST A COMMENT:
Name:  
Email address*:    
Location:  
Validation:
House Rules:  
Your Comment:  
[All comments are moderated and will not appear immediately. Your name, location and comment will be displayed on this page if your post passes moderation.]
CIARA PRIESTLY
After writing a series of blogs telling my story about my battle with cancer I now feel very compelled to write about my friend's battle. This story will no doubt shock you to the core.
MOST POPULAR GALLERIES