Catholic grammars urged to end transfer tests

Published Thursday, 25 February 2010
Comments
Toggle font size
Print

Sinn Fein Education minister Catriona Ruane has told the first conference of the Catholic Principals Association she had no intention of bringing back the 11-Plus.

"The 11-Plus was morally wrong, educationally unsound and it inflicted year on year wholly unnecessary trauma and suffering on 10 and 11-year-old children", she said on Thursday.

The conference was organised after Catholic Bishops called on all Catholic schools in Northern Ireland to abolish transfer tests within two years, formally supporting Sinn Fein's policy of ending all academic selection in the region.

"We have set 2012 as the date by which we would like academic selection to have ended," Cardinal Sean Brady told the conference.

"When people have failed an exam at 11 there could be that sense of failure already at that age and that would be deplorable," he added.

The meeting was organised by the Catholic Principals Association.

"Catholic schools are only one part of the educational landscape in Northern Ireland and we want to show leadership to the controlled sector," Dr. Seamus Quinn from Catholic Principals Association told UTV.

"The Catholic Bishops have signalled the direction of travel for the Catholic Grammar Schools, through the abandonment of academic selection. I very much welcome this positive move", Mrs Ruane said.

Grammar schools across Northern Ireland, including Catholic schools, set their own private transfer exams in 2009 after the 11-plus was abolished without political consensus for an alternative.

Earlier this month the UUP leader Sir Reg Empey told UTV his party would not sign up to the Hillsborough deal unless a "consensus" is found to solve the education debate.

"Working groups established by other parties outside the structures of our political institutions have no status and are no more than hollow publicity gimmicks. The place for debate and agreement was in the Education Committee, in the Executive and in the Assembly", Mrs Ruane said on Thursday.

"Reg and his party refused to even discuss those proposals a few years ago. We've moved on," she told UTV.

© UTV News
Comments Comments
4 Comments
lorna in limavady wrote (813 days ago):
I could be accused of bigotry here but this is my worry. With the selection test a child can enter into any Grammar school if he get the results. We see in England the Catholic faith schools are held in high esteem and parents must convert to Cathoticism in order for their child to gain a place in their schools. I fear that only Catholic children will be accepted into Catholic Grammar schools here if the selection tests are to go.
maggie in limavady wrote (817 days ago):
You have to wonder at those Catholic Bishops. A child of seven will know all there is to know about God and the Church enough to commit to it for the rest of their lives.but when it comes to education they are immature at 11. If I went by Ms Ruane my child would be going to the Grammar school being low income but I believe the local high school is more suited for him. The results of the tests have directed me to make that choice with his own ability
maggie in limavady wrote (817 days ago):
You have to wonder at those Catholic Bishops. A child of seven will know all there is to know about God and the Church enough to commit to it for the rest of their lives.but when it comes to education they are imature at 11. If I went by Ms Ruane my child would be going to the Grammar school being low income but I believe the local high school is more suited for him. The results of the tests have directed me to make that choice with his own ability
Lyndsay in Belfast wrote (817 days ago):
Personally I sat the 11-Plus and never suffered any trauma or stress through doing this. I have friends that are Primary School teachers and others with children due to go to Secondary School, and it would seem that there is more stress and hassle now than when the 11-Plus was in place
POST A COMMENT:
Name:  
Email address*:    
Location:  
Validation:
House Rules:  
Your Comment:  
[All comments are moderated and will not appear immediately. Your name, location and comment will be displayed on this page if your post passes moderation.]