Carroll killers terms 'unduly lenient'

Published Monday, 18 June 2012
Comments
Toggle font size
Print

The Court of Appeal is to review the jail terms handed down to both men convicted of killing Constable Stephen Carroll, the Director of Public Prosecutions has confirmed.

Carroll killers terms 'unduly lenient'
Brendan McConville and John Paul Wootton were sentenced in May for the murder (© Pacemaker)

John Paul Wootton, who was 17 when the policeman was gunned down in Craigavon in 2009, was sentenced to spend 14 years behind bars in May, while former Sinn Féin councillor Brendan McConville, 40, was jailed for a minimum of 25 years.

Constable Carroll's widow described the jail term handed down to Wootton as "disgusting".

Kate Carroll said she believed it was not a deterrent for other young people being lured into terrorist activity.

Days after the sentencing, Lord Justice Girvan said he was "bound and obligated" to operate within a framework which laid down "special rules" for sentencing anyone under 18 at the time of committing a murder.

A statement released by the PPS on Monday said the Director of Public Prosecutions, Barra McGrory QC "sought leave to refer the sentences imposed on both John Paul Wootton and Brendan McConville to the Court of Appeal on the ground that the sentences are unduly lenient".

Last month it was revealed that Mr McGrory was considering the jail term given to John Paul Wootton following Ms Carroll's remarks.

"Fourteen years for a life is dreadful - I've got a life sentence ahead of me, so he should too," she told UTV at the time of sentencing.

The review of the sentences given to Wootton and McConville can only be carried out by the Court of Appeal, and must be referred by the DPP.

In England and Wales guidelines dictate the minimum term for killing a police officer is 30 years, while in the Republic, anyone found guilty of murdering a Garda officer can face a minimum of 40 years behind bars.

In Northern Ireland sentencing is at the discretion of the court, but earlier this month the Justice Minister said he intended to review the "legislation governing the setting of starting tariffs for murder where the court has passed a life sentence".

David Ford said the reassessment would "include, but not be limited to, the murder of police officers" and was being undertaken following "strong public reaction to the sentence".

Constable Carroll, 48, was the first PSNI member to be killed by dissident republicans since the force replaced the RUC. Two days before his death, Sappers Mark Quinsey and Patrick Azimkar were gunned down at Massereene Army barracks.

© UTV News
Comments Comments
9 Comments
liam in belfast wrote (336 days ago):
these were fair sentences. If they had killed a civilain they would both be out in less than 14. But it seems civilians are second class citizens. Disgracefull. Politicians are turning this into a political issue, if thats the case then does that make these men political prisoners?
steve in belfast wrote (337 days ago):
@ Big C what a disgraceful comment,"the poor man got it hard" what sort of creature are you? This man went out of his way to murder another human being for no other reason than blind bigotry.25 and 14 years for cold blooded premeditated murder is hardly a deterrant to other terrorists who follow the same path.You say" during the war",would that be the war were it was ok to shoot an off duty RUC or UDR man in the back then scream for inquires into a shoot to kill policy when an IRA man was killed?
Marty in Toomebridge wrote (338 days ago):
Brendan McConville is an innocent man. Our thoughts are with his family. His Appeal against this conviction will be overturned.
David in BELFAST wrote (338 days ago):
I have always been of the opinion that the courts seem to dish out Unduly lenient sentences in ALL cases. If a person commits a crime and more importantly a murder they should be willing to accept the consenquences. In this case these 2 men both knew EXACTLY what they were setting out to do (Regardless of their age) and as such if we no longer can sentence them to the death penalty like in america then the least the courts can do is give these scum a proper LIFE sentence. LIFE should mean LIFE, not 14 or 25 years which has been given in this case.
OldSod in Fermanagh wrote (338 days ago):
40 years minimum for murder of a Garda,... I guess the life of a PSNI officer is valued at far less by our justice system.
POST A COMMENT:
Name:  
Email address*:    
Location:  
Validation:
House Rules:  
Your Comment:  
[All comments are moderated and will not appear immediately. Your name, location and comment will be displayed on this page if your post passes moderation.]
MOST POPULAR GALLERIES
On the rocks
Wed 01 May 2013
4x4 in Ballycastle harbour
Thu 02 May 2013