Basque terrorist loses extradition appeal

Published Thursday, 03 May 2012
Toggle font size

A fugitive Basque killer has lost his appeal against his extradition from Northern Ireland to face a new terrorism charge in Spain.

Basque terrorist loses extradition appeal
Jose Ignacio de Juana Chaos is believed to have fled Northern Ireland. (© UTV)

High Court judges on Thursday dismissed arguments that an invalid European Arrest Warrant was issued against Jose Ignacio de Juana Chaos.

Claims that it would be unjust or oppressive to surrender him to the Spanish authorities due to his mental state were also rejected.

Nothing has been heard from the 56-year-old since the Recorder for Belfast granted the extradition request in March 2010.

De Juana, who was jailed for his part in an ETA campaign of 25 murders, had been bailed to live with his wife in the west of the city while fighting the proceedings.

But within weeks he breached his release conditions and is believed to have fled Northern Ireland.

Despite the mystery over his current whereabouts, lawyers acting for him pressed ahead with their appeal.

Mr Justice McCloskey, sitting with Lord Chief Justice Morgan and Lord Justice Higgins, held that he was entitled to have the merits of his appeal considered in his absence.

De Juana is wanted over the contents of a letter read out in his name at a rally in San Sebastian in August 2008 which allegedly called for the armed struggle to continue.

He faces the possibility of further imprisonment if convicted of the public justification of terrorist actions which caused humiliation and intensified the grief of victims and their relatives.

Judges ruled that while the European Arrest Warrant was "unquestionably imperfect", it was nevertheless valid.

In their view de Juana's surrender to Spanish authorities would advance the aims of promoting public safety, preventing disorder or crime and protecting the rights and freedom of others under the European Convention on Human Rights.

Issues about his mental health can be raised before the Spanish judicial authorities, the court held.

Mr Justice McCloskey said: "We find that none of the grounds of appeal possesses any merit. We dismiss the appeal accordingly.

"It follows that the appellant is now liable to be extradited to Spain pursuant to and in accordance with the Recorder's order."

The judge added: "He may also be vulnerable to prosecution in this jurisdiction for breaching the terms of the bail order on which he was released following the extradition order at first instance."

De Juana's legal team later confirmed they will now consider whether to try to take their challenge to the Supreme Court in London.

© UTV News
Comments Comments
Carlos in belfast wrote (999 days ago):
I'd like to know whos paying for this as hes done a runner??? would it be the tax payers again
Rob in North Down wrote (1,000 days ago):
If we don't even know where this man is living at the minute why are NI lwayers being given public money to defend him?
ck1 in Belfast wrote (1,000 days ago):
Surely you cant be a 'fugitive' unless you've left a country unlawfully. Inaki de Juana came to Ireland freely and lived openly. He is being extradited for questioning for allegedly writing a letter, read at a protest, which nobody can produce as evidence which again allegedly stated "kick the ball forward" a term supporting Basque independence. He is the first to be extradited merely for 'questioning'. One would argue that the UN special Rappateurs report on torture, Martin Scheinin by Spanish Authorities while questioning Basque detainees was ignored.
Email address*:    
House Rules:  
Your Comment:  
[All comments are moderated and will not appear immediately. Your name, location and comment will be displayed on this page if your post passes moderation.]
January snow
Tue 13 January 2015
Ravenhill Road fish spill
Sun 25 January 2015
Wed 07 January 2015