Appeal bid over Doherty murder conviction

Published Wednesday, 20 February 2013
Toggle font size

A convicted loyalist killer jailed for another sectarian murder has launched a bid to be freed under the Royal Prerogative of Mercy, it has emerged.

Appeal bid over Doherty murder conviction
Ms Doherty was murdered on her way home in September 1973. (© Pacemaker)

Robert James Shaw Rodgers' lawyers have written to Northern Ireland Secretary Theresa Villiers urging her to grant the special pardon because he has already served a life sentence.

The 59-year-old is also preparing to lodge an immediate appeal against being found guilty of murdering Catholic teenager Eileen Doherty nearly 40 years ago.

She was shot three times after her taxi was hijacked by gunmen in south Belfast.

Ms Doherty, 19, was returning home to the west of the city from a visiting her fiance when the killing was carried out in September 1973.

Rodgers, of Tierney Gardens, Belfast, was charged following a review of available evidence by the Historical Enquiries Team (HET).

He denied the murder but was convicted last week following a non-jury trial.

A judge ruled there could be no possible innocent explanation for Rodgers' palm prints being uncovered inside the hijacked taxi.

Although not suspected of firing the fatal shots, he was found guilty of a joint enterprise to murder.

Rodgers has already served 17 years in prison for the killing of a Catholic man a year later. Ciaran McElroy, 18, was shot a number of times in September 1974 on Park End Street, Belfast.

Despite being jailed for life once more for Ms Doherty's murder, he could be free after two years under the terms of the Good Friday Agreement.

However, his lawyers have initiated legal moves aimed at securing a much sooner release.
A letter sent by Kevin R Winters Solicitors to the Secretary of State's office set out the case for issuing the Royal Prerogative.

They argued that Rodgers has already served a life sentence for a Troubles-related killing carried out in Northern Ireland - putting him in a different category to former IRA man Gerry McGeough.

Dungannon man McGeough, who was jailed for the attempted murder of a part-time soldier in 1981, failed to secure a pardon because he had not served time in British or Irish jails for other offences in Germany and the United States.

The letter sent on behalf of Rodgers states: "We believe the circumstances of this case permit the Secretary of State to give favourable consideration to the grant of the Royal Prerogative of Mercy."

The Secretary of State was put on notice that emergency judicial review proceedings will be launched if the request is refused.

Solicitor Kevin Winters also confirmed his client intends to lodge an appeal against the murder conviction.

He said the challenge would be based on the court drawing an adverse inference against Rodgers, and being deprived the chance to cross examine a key forensic police witness.

Mr Winters further claimed there was no consistent approach between the HET and Police Service of Northern Ireland.

"In not one single case involving contentious killings by the security forces has there been a referral by HET to PSNI to make an arrest," he said.

"This stands in stark contrast to the approach taken in the case of Robert Rodgers and some others like Gerry McGeough."

© UTV News
Comments Comments
Boru in Ireland wrote (708 days ago):
Eileen Doherty and Ciaran McElroy, murdered because they weren't British; murdered because they were IRISH - murdered by 'British' people with a taught hatred of everything Irish: The British Media aren't fooling anyone by constantly, ceaselessly, referring to Irish people in the north of Ireland merely as and only as..'Catholic' - referring to racial crimes as 'sectarian' doesn't make the crime somehow 'less' barbaric: "Oh what a tangled web we weave when first we practice to...deceive."
John in Newtownabbey wrote (708 days ago):
Should have come clean years ago. Horrible crime - as were all murders.
Lee in Belfast wrote (708 days ago):
Say ur a republican and u will get out , a big fat cheque and a job in government.
henry in north of ireland wrote (708 days ago):
ack poor man has already served a life sentence for murder, well thats ok but it wasnt for the murder of this young girl her only crime being a catholic, i hope this apppeal fails like it should do
Belfast in Belfast wrote (708 days ago):
If this man is innocent and it sounds like he is saying that then he must be released. But i agree with the judge. My palm prints are not in taxis that go up the shankill. I also agree with Sol Winters that the british forces including the RUC are not being put on trial. But then agaun they have lost the evidence against their mates or hidden under the excuse of not in the public interest that the British government roll out when they are covering up collusion.
Email address*:    
House Rules:  
Your Comment:  
[All comments are moderated and will not appear immediately. Your name, location and comment will be displayed on this page if your post passes moderation.]
January snow
Tue 13 January 2015
Wintry weather
Wed 28 January 2015
Ravenhill Road fish spill
Sun 25 January 2015