26 guilty over Ardoyne illegal protest

Published Thursday, 22 December 2011
Comments
Toggle font size
Print

Twenty-five men and one woman have been found guilty of staging an illegal sit-down protest at a contentious Orange Order parade on the Twelfth of July in 2010.

Video available to UK viewers only.
We’re sorry. This video is unavailable from your location.

Identification evidence was held to be strong enough to convict them all of obstructing lawful activity in public by demonstrating at the annual march last year.

Fines of £400 were imposed on each of them.

Nine defendants also found guilty of resisting arrest received additional £200 penalties.

A 27th accused was acquitted after challenging claims that had been recognised at the scene on the Crumlin Road, near the Ardoyne shopfronts in north Belfast.

Deputy District Judge Neil Rafferty said the protest was likely to have led on to later rioting by others in the area.

It certainly was the match that probably lit what became utterly disgraceful and disgusting and sickening acts of violence in this particular area.

Deputy District Judge Neil Rafferty

The charges were defended with residents and campaigners claiming they were involved in a peaceful sit-down protest which did not breach a Parades Commission determination.

Two separate bodies operating in the area have been linked to protests against the parade: the Crumlin Ardoyne Residents' Association (CARA); and the Greater Ardoyne Residents' Coalition (GARC).

The demonstration at the centre of the case was said to have been led by GARC.

During a four-day hearing at Belfast Magistrates' Court video footage was played in an attempt to identify defendants.

It showed those sitting on the road chanting "peaceful protest" at riot squad officers facing them.

Police witnesses also claimed they could pick out participants, some of whom were from Derry, from photographs taken on the day.

Amid heavy security for his judgement, Mr Rafferty described the PSNI operation at the stand-off as an example of "softly softly policing".

Although police batons were seen to be raised in parts of the footage, the judge said he did not see anyone being struck.

His comments provoked an outburst of laughter from defendants packed into the public gallery.

They were warned that any further outbursts could result in them being held in contempt of court.

At one stage, after being told one defendant lived near Omagh, Mr Rafferty commented: "There was a worrying feature that some people travelled great distances to be insulted."

He also stressed that, according to police, the accused were not involved in violence which broke out later in the area.

But he added: "In any civilised society the right protest is respected," he said.

"Lawful protest is an important means by which citizens can display their displeasure or concern regarding an event.

"With it also comes a responsibility to act lawfully."

Outside the court GARC representatives issued a statement claiming the sit-down protest had been a peaceful expression of the right to live free from "sectarian harassment".

The coalition claimed its representatives faced "trumped-up charges" but vowed not to be silenced.

It further alleged that the "sham of a trial" showed police bias and the willingness of the Parades Commission to allow sectarian parades through unwanted areas.

A police spokesperson said: "We have a commitment to all communities to address breaches of the law in whatever form.

"We are grateful to the court for the judgement today and would encourage all citizens to work with police at public events to ensure peaceful outcomes."

© UTV News
Comments Comments
28 Comments
Danso in N,Belfast wrote (145 days ago):
There you go the bigot said it all " yea well get over Danso" leave us in pease to have a respectful march we have been doing for +37 years(the queens english at it's very best), my point was that it has never been a respectful march and has only had a level of respect now because of the restrictions placed on the march. I can't speak for everyone else but yes I agree with you that it should be just like drumcree and not be allowed.....
jonny in belfast wrote (147 days ago):
@ Danso, yea well get over danso, and leave us in peace to do a march that we have been doing respectfully for the last 37+ years. do you all want this to be another drumcree?
Danso in N,Belfast wrote (149 days ago):
Just like some people on this site(bigots), I also remember the bands passing by the armys big green screen beside the bookies and yes there wasn't a protester in sight, but that didn't stop the orangemen and band members from pelting the small crowd that were just wacthing the not so innocent parade with beer bottles, all while the army and the great RUC stood by and did nothing but laugh, this is one of my not so pleasent memories, im 37 now and that happened when i was about 10 but there was other great memories of supporter dressed as orange nun's with false breasts sticking out , but then it is just an innocent parade of your orange culture and why would we ever be offend by that.....wise up bigots....and before Im called a bigot, I married a protestant and were bringing our two children up as non bigoted protestants.....
seamas in belfast wrote (149 days ago):
The great thing about being British is the right to travel anywhere you like in Britain and protest on the public highway. That’s what my grandfather fought in the war to protect. He fought so his grandson would be British and have the right to go where he liked and say what he liked. He believed British people could stand on the public highway and protest. There was no restriction on that. That wasn’t just a right for some of the people. That was a right for everyone.
micky flynn in liverpool wrote (149 days ago):
this is 2 this angie girl ive been out of ardoyne a while now and recognize all the lads an woman in that protest and yes they r all residents so y dont you crawl back in2 your scruffy whole and get ur facts rite b4 u start runnin men an woman from ardoyne for standing up 2 the RUC PSNI and the loyalist scum that walk the roads of place that im proud 2 say i come from ps can u say the same angie
POST A COMMENT:
Name:  
Email address*:    
Location:  
Validation:
House Rules:  
Your Comment:  
[All comments are moderated and will not appear immediately. Your name, location and comment will be displayed on this page if your post passes moderation.]
MOST POPULAR GALLERIES